Clergy, Staff & Vestry

Interim Rector

Father Stephen Carlsen is serving as the Interim Rector of St. Paul's. His job is to help St. Paul's envision our future and prepare for calling a new Rector. Steve grew up in the Midwest, was ordained in the Diocese of Chicago, and served in Colorado and most recently as the Dean of Christ Church Cathedral, Indianapolis. A self-proclaimed bicycle geek, on his sabbatical several years ago, Steve and his wife, Jen, went on a six-month bike tour through South America and Mexico. Both are delighted to be in Key West and look forward to further adventures! 

Steve is available for pastoral care during office hours at (305) 296-5142, Ext. 2, and after office hours on his cell at 317-414-4194.

Music Director, Organist

Tim  Peterson
After receiving his Bachelor of Music degree in voice performance and education from the University of New York at Fredonia, he graduated from Syracuse University with a Master of Music degree in Piano Performance with a concentration in accompaniment. 

He has been a church musician for over 40 years and has served in various denominations, including Presbyterian, Episcopal, Methodist, United Church of Christ, and the Evangelical Lutheran Church of America. 

Tim moved to Key West in August 2015 and  was appointed the Director of Music at St Paul’s  in December of 2016.

Vestry Officers

Senior Warden
Ray Warren



Junior Warden
Greta Ford


Vestry Members

Lonnie Gordon
Bruce Hagemann
Joseph Lyles 

Samantha Hall
Perry Hodies
Kim Malgrat

David Eyer, Treasurer
Mary Simmons, Clerk

Skip to toolbar